Stay completely out of trouble to get Permanent Residence ASAP

We sometimes get asked for assistance by people who have got their Residence and want to apply for Permanent Residence Visa (PRV) but find they are prevented by a real fish hook in the Immigration Act – section 161. People with Residence who are charged and convicted of any offence within the last two years of having held a Resident Visa (RV) cannot get a PRV because they become liable for deportation; this applies to any conviction where the court could impose jail time of no less than three months, or more. We wrote about this before here.

What’s more, people may not be aware of it until they try to apply for a PRV, and that is the surest way to get Immigration interested. The harshness of s 161 is that it sets the bar so low, and wide. A recent online search of the law books reveals over 700 criminal or civil offences with a possible imprisonment period not exceeding 3 months. This means many, if not most, minor (and also not so minor) offences will give you an immigration headache.

Remember also, the person doesn’t have to be actually imprisoned – that’s usually reserved for serious, repeat offending. People convicted of a first drink ‘n drive offence for example, might typically get a fairly modest fine and will get 6 months’ disqualification, but surely not imprisonment. They are still caught though. Immigration, if it was feeling particularly nasty, could technically deport the person where their appeal right had expired and not been exercised.

The upshot of all this is that Residents with a blot against their name must make a detailed request to the Minister to suspend their deportation liability. Otherwise they will never be able to apply for a PRV. They have a right of appeal against deportation, but the correct avenue is an approach to the Minister, who has absolute discretion. See our article in December 2013 about the deportation Appeal process here.

So just about any conviction could stall your plans to travel overseas for more than 14-days, even across the Ditch. In one particular case our Resident client with a blot against his name got a measure of success by getting a ‘good behaviour bond’ from the Minister. If he stayed out of trouble, his liability would be suspended forever. However the bond lasts for 5 years and people may not apply for a PRV in the meantime. We contested this and found it ultimately rests on how the Act and Immigration Policy are read together.

Part of the Minister’s insistence that our client stay on his Resident Visa is that getting a PRV results in an enhancement of a person’s immigration status.

Under the Act holders’ entitlements under a RV and a PRV are exactly the same. The key difference in practice however is that a PRV holder can travel in and out of NZ any time they wish and are not subject to travel and sometimes other conditions, like Residents.

The bottom line for Residents then is this: if you get into trouble and your liability is suspended then enhancing your ‘status’ to enable extended overseas travel may be road-blocked for many years.

About samuelames

Staff Solicitor at Laurent Law
This entry was posted in Immigration Problems, Immigration Visas and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Stay completely out of trouble to get Permanent Residence ASAP

  1. Jacky says:

    Hi there, I just want to check if someone hold PRV visa and have any conviction after getting PRV visa. Then INZ can still deport them from NZ or they can’t.


    • If the conviction is for an offence for which the Court could imprison someone for 2 years or more, then they could still face deportation action. The sentence that the Court actually delivers is irrelevant.


      • Jacky says:

        Hi Mr Laurent,
        Just want to clear on how immigration consider the 2 year or more sentence. Suppose if someone got convicted under any section which has power to impose maximum punishment seven year. But due to their past character and considering other facts court gives 2 years or more in prison, But in actual they just serve less than 2 years in prison or get home detention for 12 months. Are they still liable for deportation.


      • It doesn’t matter what sentence they actually got. They are liable for deportation if the Court can impose the maximum sentence, even if the Court does not give the maximum.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s